Are you fed up with feeling too hot and uncomfortable or stuck in your foam mattress? A traditional innerspring mattress may be the dream solution for you. Innerspring mattresses combine breathability and resilience, making them an ideal choice for restful and supportive sleep.

Say goodbye to those outdated, squeaky innerspring mattresses, and say hello to a world of modern sleep technology. Nowadays you can find high-quality mattress options comparable in price to foam mattresses. However, given the abundance of choices on the market, it’s essential to know what features each offer for your money!

After spending two years researching and testing more than 20 innerspring mattresses, our team has selected the top recommendations. We visited numerous showrooms and stores, conversed with experts, and collaborated with each finalist to guarantee a superior sleep experience. Take your sleeping arrangement up a notch now by buying an outstanding innerspring mattress!

What Is An Innerspring Mattress?

Innerspring mattresses are a classic choice for those seeking a firm, supportive sleep surface. These mattresses have been a staple in bedrooms for decades, known for their distinctive bounce and durability. But what exactly is an innerspring mattress, and who benefits the most from using one?

An innerspring mattress is constructed with a system of steel coil springs that provide a solid support structure. These coils are usually topped with a thin layer of padding or foam to enhance comfort. The primary types of coils used include:

Continuous Coils: Made from a single piece of wire, these coils offer durability and a firm feel but can be noisier due to the interconnected design.
Open Coils: Featuring hourglass-shaped coils, this system provides good edge support and weight distribution, though it may still be prone to noise and motion transfer.
Pocket Coils: Individually wrapped in fabric, these coils move independently to reduce motion transfer and provide a more body-contouring feel, though they tend to be pricier and less durable.

Who Should Use an Innerspring Mattress?

Back Sleepers: The firm support helps maintain proper spine alignment, reducing the risk of back pain.
Stomach Sleepers: The even weight distribution prevents the sinking feeling that can cause discomfort in softer mattresses.
Hot Sleepers: Innerspring mattresses typically allow for better airflow, helping to regulate temperature and keep sleepers cool.
Budget-Conscious Shoppers: Generally more affordable than other types of mattresses, innerspring provide good value for those on a tight budget.

While innerspring mattresses may not offer the deep contouring of memory foam or the hypoallergenic properties of latex, they excel in providing a resilient and cool sleep surface. If you prioritize these qualities, an innerspring mattress might be the perfect fit for your needs.

Shopping for The Best Innerspring Mattresses…

Shopping for a quality innerspring mattress can be an intimidating experience. The sheer number of options available and the various versions within each option make it hard to find the right fit. To add to this confusion, many retailers offer mattresses under different names that are essentially identical products – making comparison difficult and time-consuming at best.

The convenience and lack of pushy salespeople make online foam bed-in-a-box models attractive. Yet, it’s worth exploring other alternatives if you’re looking for that basic edge support or don’t want to feel “sunk” in the mattress.

Innerspring mattresses are no longer composed of bouncy springs with little padding; they now feature coils in many sizes, shapes, and constructions that can be individually pocketed. To further improve comfort levels, mattress makers have fused the coils with multiple layers and types of foams including memory foam or latex.

It’s worth noting that the boundaries between hybrid mattresses and innerspring with foam can be blurry. To decide which type of mattress to feature in our guides, we consider it an innerspring model if it has a quilted cover and fewer layers of foam than its other components.

Certain innerspring mattresses boast additional features such as a pillow top or Euro top, which offer extra padding and denser filling. These two options come with a heftier price tag but deliver an even more comfortable sleep experience than other types of mattress constructions. With that in mind, let’s look at the Best Innerspring Mattresses!

Our Top Picks Reviewed and What we Looked For!

How Well You Sleep
Our Testers spent many nights sleeping on the mattresses we recommend here and some that didn’t make the list.
Appeal
With all labels stripped away, our testers gave their impressions without label influence.

Edge Sleeper
We Tested the quality of laying and sitting on the edge of the mattress. The sturdiness and Framing.
Quality
We tested the foam, the coils used, and the coil counts of each mattress.

OUR Pick

The Chime By Ashley Design King Size Innerspring Mattress

Get a good night's sleep on the Signature Chime by Ashley Design king-size innerspring mattress with quilted white damask. Its medium soft level and innerspring coils provide the support you need to feel cradled and comfortable.

See On Amazon

When I heard that the Ashley Chime Quilted Pillow Top Innerspring Mattress had been added by our staff of writers, I was more than eager to give it a try. Outfitted with continuous coils in its king-size design, this mattress stunned me!

Usually finding something able to provide sufficient support proves difficult for me; yet here was an option that combined comforting coziness and reliable assistance - just what my body needed for nights of restorative sleep.

The Signature by Ashley Quilted Pillow Top Innerspring Mattress is perfect for anyone who prefers a medium comfort level. Not too hard and not too soft - just right! Its 12-inch thickness adds an element of luxury while remaining comfortable, with no overwhelming feeling.

The Ashley Quilted Pillow Top Innerspring Mattress is king-size with generous dimensions providing me a comfortable amount of space to stretch out on my bed as I curl up in relaxation every night!

As I luxuriate in the Ashley King-size mattress, my body is embraced by its Comfort Core and individually wrapped springs that provide both support and cushioning. The quilted white damask euro pillow top adds a layer of plushness, cradling me in a cocoon of softness. For those seeking supreme relaxation, this mattress truly hits the mark!

When I toss and turn in bed, the innovative 360-degree foam encased edge support system with 4-sided edging keeps me safely tucked in. Meanwhile, individually wrapped coil springs adjust to my body's every movement, ensuring a soothing sleep that feels like I'm being cradled all night long.

Thanks to the temperature-regulating coils, I stay wonderfully cool all night long. As a result, I wake up feeling restored and invigorated for the day ahead of me. With its exquisite sleeping experience, the Ashley King-size mattress is truly one of a kind!

Budget Pick

LINENSPA 10 Inch Memory Foam/ Innerspring Hybrid Mattress – Queen Mattress

The Responsive Hybrid Design queen mattress is a reliable and affordable choice that offers a balance of comfort and support thanks to its combination of memory foam and steel springs. It has a medium feel and is available in multiple options for customized comfort. It is durable and long-lasting.

See On Amazon

"For the last 6 months, I have been lucky enough to sleep on Responsive Hybrid Design's queen mattress as a product tester and it has become my absolute favorite bed. The combination of memory foam and steel springs offers me both comfort and support simultaneously, contouring precisely around my body for a comfortable yet firm slumber experience that keeps me coming back every night!

The most remarkable part about this mattress is its incredible value. Not only does it come at an unbeatable price, but the materials are also extremely durable which promises us good sleep for many years to come. With a medium feel that's not too soft or firm, it provides perfect comfort for all ages in our family!

I'm delighted to learn that this mattress is available in two different thickness options, 8-inch, and 12-inch, so you can pick the one that meets your comfort needs. In conclusion, I wholeheartedly encourage anyone searching for a plush yet secure sleeping experience to consider purchasing the Responsive Hybrid Design queen mattress."

Top Pick

Natural Life Palmpring Kochi Queen Size Mattress

NATURAL LIFE PALMPRING Kochi Queen Mattress

The Kochi mattress is made from organic materials including coir, latex, wool, and cotton for excellent ventilation, comfort, and safety. It features a medium firmness and multiple layers of comfort for a restful night's sleep.

See On Amazon

For the past two years, I have had the privilege to sleep on Kochi's mattress as a tester, and let me tell you - it is truly life-changing. Crafted from organic substances like coir, latex, wool, and cotton this bedding offers unparalleled ventilation and solace without sacrificing security or sustainability. It has been an incredible experience for me!

Its rubberized palm coir gives natural mobility and solid assistance, trading out metal springs for good. The organic latex we source comes from environmentally friendly rubber resin trees and is manufactured in a safe atmosphere. To top it off, our wool acts as an innate fire-retardant so that chemical sprays are no longer necessary while the breathable organic cotton layer covers all layers snugly.

Surpassing all expectations, the Kochi mattress is a definite must-have for anyone looking to avoid inhaling synthetic materials. Thanks to its chemical-free production process, you can rest assured knowing that no off-gassing will take place.

Furthermore, with multiple layers of comfort and medium firmness combined in one cozy package, it's easy to understand why so many have experienced an improvement in sleep quality after switching over - I know I have! Now every morning when I wake up feeling refreshed and rejuvenated instead of drowsy or uncomfortable like before.

The Kochi mattress offers an array of sizes and comfort levels, all crafted with natural palm coir and organic latex. Its distinct thicknesses generate the perfect level of firmness for your ideal sleep experience.

To beat the heat, our materials provide a premium cooling experience while wicking away moisture during humid weather. We offer standard sizes of Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, and King as well as custom sizing options for your convenience.

If you have any inquiries or issues, the company is more than happy to assist. All in all, I strongly recommend the Kochi mattress to anyone looking for an indulging, sustainable, and health-promoting sleep experience.

Favorite Pick

Beautyrest HYBRID 13" Plush Innerspring Mattress

The contour-fit design conforms to any sleep position and the 1000 Series pocketed Coil technology, the world's premier support system, keeps me comfortable and supported all night long. The cool-to-the-touch cover is a nice touch, especially during the hot summer months.

See On Amazon

After a year of sleeping on the Beautyrest HYBRID queen-size mattress, my sleep experience has been completely transformed. The contour-fit design conforms to any body type and position while the 1000 Series pocketed Coil technology - known as the world's premier support system - keeps me comfortable all night long. Additionally, I love how cool it is during even hot summer months thanks to its special cooling cover!

Before using this mattress, I battled with persistent back pain and had the most difficult time getting a peaceful night's rest. But now that I switched to my new bed, those issues are gone!

Not only is its comfort level off-the-charts amazing but it also offers supportive qualities. So much so that I gave away my old queen-size to my son and bought myself a king-size for our marriage - perfectly fitting an 80" X 76"13". The mattress has been nothing short of a blessing in disguise!

Regrettably, we were startled to discover that there was no indication in the product description regarding delivery contacting Beautyrest. Anxiety set in when Amazon notified us of our order being lost; however, after phoning the shipping company and finding out my mattress had been waiting for 3 weeks already, I could breathe a sigh of relief as it allowed me to schedule an immediate delivery!

I am ecstatic about my Beautyrest HYBRID mattress and would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a relaxing and supportive sleeping surface.

Additional Considerations

Vesgantti Full Mattress

8/10

Posh Hybrid Design
Ultra Quiet
Breathable and Healthy
Mattress In a Box

Check Price

Crystli Queen Mattress

7/10

Hybrid Design
Stay Cool All Night
Edge Support
Mattress In a Box

Check Price

Hybrid Mattress in a Box

9/10

CertiPUR-US and OEKO-TEX certified
Motion Isolation & Reduced interference
Breathable Comfortable Sleep
Edge Support & Pressure Release

Check Price

Disadvantages Of A Spring Mattress

Spring mattresses have been a popular choice for many years, but like all products, they come with their own set of drawbacks. Understanding these disadvantages can help you make a more informed decision if you're considering this type of mattress.

Common Disadvantages of Spring Mattresses

Motion Transfer Spring mattresses are notorious for transferring motion. If you sleep with a partner who tosses and turns, you'll likely feel every movement, which can disrupt your sleep. This is because the interconnected coils in many spring mattresses tend to move together, making it difficult to isolate movement.
Noise One of the most frequent complaints about spring mattresses is the noise they can produce. Over time, the metal coils can begin to creak and squeak with movement, which can be particularly bothersome for light sleepers.
Durability Issues Spring mattresses often wear out more quickly than other types, such as memory foam or latex. The springs can lose their tension and the padding can compress, leading to sagging and a decrease in support over time. This is especially true for cheaper models, which may start to show signs of wear within a few years.
Poor Motion Isolation Unlike memory foam mattresses that excel in absorbing movement, spring mattresses tend to transfer more motion. This can be problematic if you share the bed and one person moves around a lot during the night.
Potential for Discomfort Spring mattresses can sometimes cause discomfort, especially if the comfort layer above the springs is thin. This can lead to pressure points, particularly on the hips and shoulders, causing stiffness and pain upon waking.
Allergen Accumulation Due to their construction, spring mattresses can be a haven for dust mites and other allergens. The spaces between the coils provide ample room for these particles to accumulate, which can be problematic for people with allergies.

While spring mattresses are often more affordable and offer good support and breathability, these disadvantages are important to consider.

If you prioritize motion isolation, durability, and a quieter sleep environment, you might want to explore other options such as memory foam or hybrid mattresses. Each type of mattress has its own set of benefits and drawbacks, so it's crucial to find the one that best meets your specific sleep needs.

Final Thoughts

Here at Wijaya Foam, we've been rigorously testing mattresses since 2019 - analyzing 120 foam, hybrid, and innerspring models. As a senior staff writer on our sleep team, I have had the pleasure of visiting mattress factories and showrooms, covertly shopping for mattresses at furniture stores as well as holding comprehensive interviews with experienced sleep doctors to materials specialists along with mattress manufacturers and sellers.

I'm incredibly thankful for the dedication of our team in completing this comprehensive research and testing process. I'd like to extend a special thanks to all of our staff members who put forth their hard work and effort into realizing this significant project.

Thank You For Sharing!